primal defense
Veteran
- Joined
- Nov 4, 2013
- Messages
- 6,997
By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our Texas Longhorns message board community.
SignUp Now!Ward is a 5' 10" converted WR who Herman coached up into a very good CFB quarterback. Elite? Hardly.Which brings up a point: elite quarterback play is everything. Herman has had it at UH with Greg Ward Jr. The only blemish on his team’s record last year—that loss at UConn—came when Ward was unable to play, so Herman is 0-1 without his star QB.
Cut it out with the politics people. It's an interesting take. It gives CS a whole helluvalot of passes but it's still an interesting take. Everyone here knows Mack left us with nothing and Charlie gave walking papers to the rest. And then he was trying to win games with guys who simply can't play quarterback. What guys out there right now making any plays at all did Charlie inherit? Nobody. Tim Cole? Perkins? Dylan Haines? Come on. Warrick, Leonard, Oliver, Boyette? Um okay. And now we finally have a QB but he's a freaking true freshman. If we win 8 with the bowl game, Charlie stays, simple.
Think about it this way: if we fire Charlie with 8 wins and he gets hired by a decent power 5 program with a decent roster and wins 10 games how are you going to feel when we're still trying to win / clean this thing up? You're going to feel as bad as you deserve to feel if you want to fire the guy after winning 8 IMO. Charile may or not be the answer but he didn't win 10/11 games at L'ville by fluke.
I didn't even have to mention that he's universally respected and adored. Oh, and he's our first black head coach. The University of Texas, by God. Call it whatever you want but if you're smart you error on the side of not being quick with the hook.
"First Black Coach".....What the hell does that have to do with anything? What a PC BS that statement is.Cut it out with the politics people. It's an interesting take. It gives CS a whole helluvalot of passes but it's still an interesting take. Everyone here knows Mack left us with nothing and Charlie gave walking papers to the rest. And then he was trying to win games with guys who simply can't play quarterback. What guys out there right now making any plays at all did Charlie inherit? Nobody. Tim Cole? Perkins? Dylan Haines? Come on. Warrick, Leonard, Oliver, Boyette? Um okay. And now we finally have a QB but he's a freaking true freshman. If we win 8 with the bowl game, Charlie stays, simple.
Think about it this way: if we fire Charlie with 8 wins and he gets hired by a decent power 5 program with a decent roster and wins 10 games how are you going to feel when we're still trying to win / clean this thing up? You're going to feel as bad as you deserve to feel if you want to fire the guy after winning 8 IMO. Charile may or not be the answer but he didn't win 10/11 games at L'ville by fluke.
I didn't even have to mention that he's universally respected and adored. Oh, and he's our first black head coach. The University of Texas, by God. Call it whatever you want but if you're smart you error on the side of not being quick with the hook.
So the very last thing I said was an aside in reference to the PC label and that's what you come back with? You've got problems."First Black Coach".....What the hell does that have to do with anything? What a PC BS that statement is.
Think about it this way: if we fire Charlie with 8 wins and he gets hired by a decent power 5 program with a decent roster and wins 10 games how are you going to feel when we're still trying to win / clean this thing up?
I'll turn the question around. How are you going to feel if we don't fire Charlie and he's still trying to win/clean this thing up next year while Tom Herman goes to a major power and wins 10 games.
Fair enough. But i won't feel as bad.
Oh, and he's our first black head coach.
What the hell does that have to do with his performance? Or this discussion?
I was responding to the PC thing which make it precisely relevant. It's also relevant to the politics of firing him in a situation that could go either way. Of course you get that.
Call it whatever you want but if you're smart you error on the side of not being quick with the hook.
Some people will tell you that when you know a decision should be made that it's smarter to go ahead and make it instead of putting it off.
Again fair enough. But "when" is the whole debate. We'll see. I think he should be gone with 7 wins personally.