Welcome to the HornSports Forum

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our Texas Longhorns message board community.

SignUp Now!

What should matter more in terms of tournament resumes?

utisdabomb12

V.I.P.
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
8,338
Who you beat? Or who you lose to? The correct answer is probably both matter, but it's an interesting question. Look at a team like Purdue. 

Purdue is 18-10 and 11-5 in the Big 10. They have good but not great wins @Indiana, at home against Ohio State, at home against Indiana, at home against BYU and at home against Iowa. 

Purdue has losses to North Florida, Vanderbilt, Gardner Webb, Minnesota and Kansas State. All of which are pretty bad losses. 

Should that resume get in over a team that's 18-10 with only 1 or 2 good wins but 0 bad losses? 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Byu just won at Zaga. Beating them looks pretty good.

There are 300+ teams in d1. Is Texas one of the top 60-something of them? Yeah...probably. Or maybe. Is that the question?

 
Byu just won at Zaga. Beating them looks pretty good.

There are 300+ teams in d1. Is Texas one of the top 60-something of them? Yeah...probably. Or maybe. Is that the question?
My question isn't Texas related. 

Rather it's a general question of what should matter more in terms of a tournament resume. If you have two teams that are 18-10, are you taking the team with 4/5 good wins but 4/5 bad losses or the team with 1/2 good wins but only 1/2 bad losses? I know other factors probably come into play like how you finish and overall RPI. 

I agree beating BYU looks good, but I don't consider that a great win since BYU is a bubble type team. Purdue is one of those tricky teams on the bubble. A handful of pretty good wins but a handful of pretty bad losses.

I tend to believe the narrative that "beating RPI top 50 teams matter since those are likely tournament teams". On the other hand, I also believe losing to teams like Gardner Webb, North Florida and Vandy means you are probably an inconsistent team. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would weight conference play greater than non-conference.The team playing at the end of conference play is much more likely to be the same team playing in March than one in December. You would have a lot more teams playing tougher non-conf schedules if this were the case. There is simply too much turnover in college basketball from year to year for most programs to schedule a non-conference schedule with clout and survive it.

 
Back
Top Bottom