Welcome to the HornSports Forum

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our Texas Longhorns message board community.

SignUp Now!

The Top 10

it's kinda Ash, then a looonnng drop off to #2. but all in all a good list.

nit-picking, but if anything i'd move P/PK even higher. it's one of those things you don't appreciate enough unless you don't have one (or both). how many times did a FG save us in Mack's tenure? imagine if Hunter Lawrence, Justin Tucker and Dusty Mangum had missed? 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
it's kinda Ash, then a looonnng drop off to #2. but all in all a good list.

nit-picking, but if anything i'd move P/PK even higher. it's one of those things you don't appreciate enough unless you don't have one (or both). how many times did a FG save us in Mack's tenure? imagine if Hunter Lawrence, Justin Tucker and Dusty Mangum had missed?
I don't disagree. I almost put them at number two, but it's nearly impossible to rank them, outside Ash.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
it's kinda Ash, then a looonnng drop off to #2. but all in all a good list.

nit-picking, but if anything i'd move P/PK even higher. it's one of those things you don't appreciate enough unless you don't have one (or both). how many times did a FG save us in Mack's tenure? imagine if Hunter Lawrence, Justin Tucker and Dusty Mangum had missed?
I was thinking the same thing regarding the kickers. With the offense seemingly going to a possession style this year, I think points might come at a premium. The efficiency of a field goal kicker after a time consuming drive could be a big difference between a win and a loss. The effectiveness of a punter is also a difference between an opponent starting in between the 10 and 20 yard line as opposed to the 30 and 40, which effects both the defense as well as the potential starting point of the offense.

Great article. I love the fact that you have Espinoza so high on your list. In my mind, the offensive line is the most important position group on the field. With a good offensive line, you can win big games with an average QB.

 
The challenge to me is finding room on this list for Shipley, Brown & Reed. It's impossible to think of them as anything but critical to the team....but who can you justifiably bump off Marian's list?

 
The challenge to me is finding room on this list for Shipley, Brown & Reed. It's impossible to think of them as anything but critical to the team....but who can you justifiably bump off Marian's list?
Good point. Everyone on that list belongs.

 
Early this morning, Austin sports radio was debating the most important players for this season. It's not exactly a new idea, but it did make me smile since it came on the heels of Marian's list.

 
The placement of Dom Espinosa at #2 was justified in my opinion.  He needs to be a beast on the line this year if Ash is going to have success. 

 
Like I said, obviously there are players who are not on the list who are key (Shipley first and foremost), but I was trying to think outside the box a bit. 

It was a challenge; that's for sure. 

 
Malcom Brown and Ced Reed are CRITICAL to our D, ahead of even Diggs. . .

If Swaim is on your list then the #3 WR is largely moot (though with Ship going down .. .maybe not). . .we aren't going to be running much 3 wide.   Frankly the JUCO TE or Jennings/McFarland are actually more important in my mind to the run game and offense. . .

Sorry, Dom is too high today . .. .Jake can take his place without a huge loss of talent. . .now had you listed the OL as a group, then very much yes. . .they have to gel.

the Brown/Reed combo or either as individuals far outweight Desmond Jackson . .. 

JMHO of course but I am thinking .. .which players if gone, hurt the worst. . . .

 
Malcom Brown and Ced Reed are CRITICAL to our D, ahead of even Diggs. . .

If Swaim is on your list then the #3 WR is largely moot (though with Ship going down .. .maybe not). . .we aren't going to be running much 3 wide.   Frankly the JUCO TE or Jennings/McFarland are actually more important in my mind to the run game and offense. . .

Sorry, Dom is too high today . .. .Jake can take his place without a huge loss of talent. . .now had you listed the OL as a group, then very much yes. . .they have to gel.

the Brown/Reed combo or either as individuals far outweight Desmond Jackson . .. 

JMHO of course but I am thinking .. .which players if gone, hurt the worst. . . .
Again, I don't disagree, but I was looking to create a list of "not so obvious." Again, thinking outside the box. 

:)

 
I think you can make a list of the "10 players who will have a big impact you aren't thinking about today" list .. . but your title was the 10 most important players for the horns this fall .. . . 

And I'm paranoid right now. . . this season can go sideways fast with a couple injuries. . . 

 
I think you can make a list of the "10 players who will have a big impact you aren't thinking about today" list .. . but your title was the 10 most important players for the horns this fall .. . . 

And I'm paranoid right now. . . this season can go sideways fast with a couple injuries. . . 
Duly noted, but again, I didn't want to throw out the obvious ten players. There would be little interest in that. Not very debatable. For example, I was going at it from the angle that we already know Shipley is key. We already know Ced and Brown (DE) are key, but we also know what they're going to do, barring injury. There are some I included, like M. Brown (RB) b/c he's known for his injury problems. My list, I suppose, would be more of a "Key players you may not expect" or something along those lines of people who have question marks around them (be it experience or injuries), that are key to this team's success. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Clearly, going forward we need more specifics about the true meaning of a post and what defines a 'top 10 most important.' The ambiguity obviously is troubling to many.

Tighten it up Hinton.

Indeed. . .

The beatings will continue until moral improves!!!!

 
Solid list but I think I'd be inclined to replace Swaim with Whiteley as the receiving TE. Swaim is a helluva blocker and will play plenty but his hands aren't real reliable apparently.

 
Back
Top Bottom