Welcome to the HornSports Forum

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our Texas Longhorns message board community.

SignUp Now!

To redshirt or not to redshirt. That is the question.

I was thinking that they should keep his redshirt, but they may have to play Heard to generate excitement for 2015 recruits. Something has to happen quick or were going to lose skill players. Playing him might generate the excitement where recruits want to play with him, whether we win or lose. Plus, I think Heard could actually run the read-option well.

 
Did it take Strong 5 years in a system he changed at Louisville?
Dobbs----I'm one of those guys that could turn around and tomorrow argue directly opposite of what I posted. Don't take me too seriously.  At the moment, I'm just pissed off that we've had such terrible offensive production this year. IMO...Swoopes is never going to be the Bridgewater type QB that Charley needs to run this team. Therefore..go ahead and let Heard try.

Four years should be enough for any QB at UT. If they don't have what it takes to get the job finished in 4 years, we probably didn't get the right one to begin with. We allegedly have the next super star coming in as a freshman next year. Then go out and get another one for 2016. If Charley can't do that, it's on him. No reason in the world that we ought not be able to recruit at least one serviceable QB every year...and manage to keep him here.

 
imo, as a general rule, all QBs and OLs should redshirt. if you are going to play them, give them meaningful snaps. that is where the previous regime hurt both Simms and Gilbert. when catastrophe caused them to play, they were not ready because the coaches had not allowed them meaningful snaps during the season.

 
imo, as a general rule, all QBs and OLs should redshirt. if you are going to play them, give them meaningful snaps. that is where the previous regime hurt both Simms and Gilbert. when catastrophe caused them to play, they were not ready because the coaches had not allowed them meaningful snaps during the season.
Wholeheartedly agree. Do not burn their shirts for token appearances.

 
Up to this point I have to believe that the coaches have gone with TS because they believe he gives Texas the best chance to win and until that changes I don't think you play Heard at all.

Once the coaches feel Heard is even with TS now there a decision to make. If Heard gets to that point in the next two weeks I think it's time to make the change and don't look back. Turn the keys over to Heard and let him play out the rest of the season.

 
I would take the shirt off Heard and play him.  Once that decision is made, then he is your guy the rest of the year and you have a head start on next year.  Heard would have more success than Swoopes based on the current personnel on offense.  The WR corp is void of explosiveness and Heard's ability to move in the pocket could extend plays and allow dead plays an opportunity to develop into big plays.

Heard isn't 6'5 225 and won't be leaving early to play in the NFL.  My decision to play isn't to save this year, but get him the much needed experience so that the team can take a step forward next year.

 
I am saying very little these days after voicing my opinion last week on the "State of the Program".  That being said, I think that our situation is difficult to compare to anyones due to the inexperience of the offensive line.  That is a game-changer, no pun intended.  You can throw out most comparisons when you have an inexperienced offensive line, with players playing out of position, playing in their second, or third year in a college strength and conditioning program.  That changes the equation, the variables, the regression analysis, and the outcome.  You cannot predict anything.

I take heart that Wickline is the o-line coach, and they are improving.  James returning make a big difference.  If we improve as much this week, I expect improved results.  I think Ty had a bad game, but that happens to second year players.  OU can be beaten.  I think we can do it if we hit on all cylinders.  Will we?  I don't know, but I will be in the Cotton Bowl.

Hook 'em!  See 'ya.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I must admit that I had an immediate knee-jerk reaction that "Swoopes isn't the guy" after the Baylor game. I've backed off that a bit as the sting of losing a winnable game fades; he still may not be the guy, but he's only started 4 games so I think we all need to cut him a little slack. He showed improvement in his 2nd and 3rd games before backsliding last weekend. It happens to young quarterbacks. I recall my last year on the 40 acres watching VY and Chance Mock split time and thinking "VY is just never going to get it," because he'd look so unbelievably lost at times. We all know how that turned out...

That said, I think the coaching staff really needs to be giving Heard some meaningful snaps (though maybe not this week). I hate to use the dreaded "two qb system" but in this case it might be warranted since we're already down to the 2nd string QB. Heard is always one play away from being forced in there due to injury so you may as well prep him. I guess you run the risk of "stunting his development" but if he's that mentality fragile then he's likely not going to be what we're expecting anyway. In a season like this, I think you have to just figure out who your building blocks are in real game action.

 
Back
Top Bottom