Welcome to the HornSports Forum

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our Texas Longhorns message board community.

SignUp Now!

Notre Dame AD Has a Vision of 2 Collegiate Athletic Associations

J.B. TexasEx

Veteran
Joined
Aug 29, 2012
Messages
9,807
“Forget the economics, the cultural divide in college athletics is getting too big,†Swarbrick said. “Any business association requires commonality of interests to hold together. It's a decision the Ivy League made a long time ago. Other schools will say, ‘Hey, we're comfortable with sort of semi-pro model.' That's a perfectly valid choice. But for some of us that's not a choice we're prepared to make and we won't.â€
CBSSports.com story by Dennis Dodd here

 
Last edited by a moderator:
interesting read. so basically football factories on one side, 'real' institutes of higher learning on the other.

 
CBSSports.com story by Dennis Dodd here
From what he says, I guess Notre Dame is prepared to fight the inevitable lawsuits. I believe we need two associations, but the two lists in the article won't work. Unless one group robs the revenue from the other.

 
interesting read. so basically football factories on one side, 'real' institutes of higher learning on the other.
Essentially, yes

Although I doubt anyone in UT's administration building looks at us as a "football factory". They probably say we're aligned closer to Stanford and UVA. I'm actually on the fence about where I'd like to see UT. On one hand, I like watching the best athletes perform. But, on the other hand, I don't think many of our CFB and BB recruits can get into UT solely on their academic merits.

True minor leagues - funded by the NFL and NBA - would potentially rectify this problem if they got rid of their age restrictions (one & done). But, why would they make that enormous capital investment? They've got a bird's nest on the ground right now - FREE player development paid for by universities. Cha-ching!

We sold our souls long ago for athletic success. Yeah, I know we haven't compromised ourselves as badly as Nebraska and many SEC teams by allowing partial qualifiers in.

IMO, there's no easy solution - but Swarbrick's vision is certainly feasible.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have been saying for a long time that in the next round of realignment, there won't be any SEC, Big 12, Big 10 or Pac. People who are stuck thinking of evolutionary change in college athletics are simply wrong.

And if a school competes in one structure for football, it doesn't mean they will be in the same structure for other sports. Schools like Alabama and Kentucky have no business playing each other in either football or basketball. 

 
I have been saying for a long time that in the next round of realignment, there won't be any SEC, Big 12, Big 10 or Pac. People who are stuck thinking of evolutionary change in college athletics are simply wrong.

And if a school competes in one structure for football, it doesn't mean they will be in the same structure for other sports. Schools like Alabama and Kentucky have no business playing each other in either football or basketball. 

Hal Mumme says hi :)

 
I have been saying for a long time that in the next round of realignment, there won't be any SEC, Big 12, Big 10 or Pac. People who are stuck thinking of evolutionary change in college athletics are simply wrong.

And if a school competes in one structure for football, it doesn't mean they will be in the same structure for other sports. Schools like Alabama and Kentucky have no business playing each other in either football or basketball. 
10 years ago, they were saying the same about baylor playing texas in football.

the article and accompanying proposed split was 'a morph of 'little guys' and 'smart schools' on one side and football centric schools on the other.

i know it's the ND AD throwing this out, but hard to imagine them alligning themselves with the former and basically saying goodbye to the big-boy football world. if indeed that's what he's implying here.

 
10 years ago, they were saying the same about baylor playing texas in football.

the article and accompanying proposed split was 'a morph of 'little guys' and 'smart schools' on one side and football centric schools on the other.

i know it's the ND AD throwing this out, but hard to imagine them alligning themselves with the former and basically saying goodbye to the big-boy football world. if indeed that's what he's implying here.
Notre Dame will never turn its back on its football tradition and give up major college football. That isn't going to happen. Basketball and Olympic sports are another issue entirely, though. 

Economic changes are unquestionably blowing through college sports. Added expense of paying players will cause some schools (especially the ones already spending upward of $10 million/yr to subsidize athletics) to rethink their commitment to playing major college sports. When that happens, look for broadcasters to pitch a whole new structure for college athletics. Conferences aligned along geographic considerations are already becoming a thing of the past. Soon schools will align along economic considerations and the group of schools in the football alliance won't be the same as the ones in the basketball, baseball, volleyball or various Olympic sport alliances. West Virginia may or may not have an interest in aligning with Texas and OU in football, but for softball and both men's and women's basketball, it makes no sense for them to be aligned with Big 12 schools. Kentucky playing Mississippi State or Alabama generates no real revenue and makes no sense.

Games in major college sports are valuable assets for certain teams. The schools with the highest values games need to be playing each other more often to maximize revenues. College sports will soon move to accommodate a model that matches up more valuable franchises more often and let the less valued franchises compete on a different level with lower expenses. Just look at UT's home schedule for this fall and ask yourself how many more price hikes is Steveo going to be able to shove down the throats of the fans to watch that craptastic schedule? The Big 10 adding Rutgers and Maryland just means games people want to actually watch happen less often. Conference networks are the last opportunity to wring more money out of the current system. Pretty soon, things are going to radically change.

 
I miss the old SWC, and kern tips, and the knothole section and those wonderful old programs with the dirk west cartoon mascots on the front, and being able to ride my bike to games at memorial stadium, and running on the field after the games and begging our heroes for their chin straps, and the thanksgiving day parade, and our bonfire ( a real bonfire and not that engineered pile of sticks 100 miles east of here), and the old roundup time in the spring, and old Clark Field and billy goat hill, and panty raids, and the orangebull, and mooreburgers, and the chicken shack, and G&M steakhouse, and the free outdoor theater on the east mall, and stuffed like a sardine can games at old gregory gym and ..........(sigh).....

I wish I had a time machine, what wouldn't I give for a time machine, and of course I do, but it's only in my mind and not real, but it was, so it sort of is, and it ...........will have to do.

 
I miss the old SWC, and kern tips, and the knothole section and those wonderful old programs with the dirk west cartoon mascots on the front
Memories.....of the way we were

SWC-family-portrait-1968-small.jpg


 
I miss the old SWC, and kern tips, and the knothole section and those wonderful old programs with the dirk west cartoon mascots on the front, and being able to ride my bike to games at memorial stadium, and running on the field after the games and begging our heroes for their chin straps, and the thanksgiving day parade, and our bonfire ( a real bonfire and not that engineered pile of sticks 100 miles east of here), and the old roundup time in the spring, and old Clark Field and billy goat hill, and panty raids, and the orangebull, and mooreburgers, and the chicken shack, and G&M steakhouse, and the free outdoor theater on the east mall, and stuffed like a sardine can games at old gregory gym and ..........(sigh).....

I wish I had a time machine, what wouldn't I give for a time machine, and of course I do, but it's only in my mind and not real, but it was, so it sort of is, and it ...........will have to do.
Slim, you and I are one the same page. Big money has made college sports less fun than they used to be. I loved the games at Gregory Gym, where the fans were right on the floor. It was noisy and fun. And there was always the fight after the game when the Aggies came over.

It was also fun watching guys go up the hill after a long fly ball. Texas players had an advantage there, they were used to it.

Round Up and the Texas Relays were always a high point of the Spring. The parade, with the frat floats and the beer kegs scattered up and down Guadelupe was always fun. Then the administrators decided we were having too much fun.

For football games we couldn't go to, Kern Tips broadcasting on the radio for the Humble Oil and Refining Company could make you feel like you were actually there.

The Chicken Shack had the best hot rolls and honey you could find, and the chicken was pretty good as well. Cold beer at Dirty Martin's was awfully good as well, particularly if you got them to take your fake ID. LOL

You stirred up a lot of memories.

Those were great days, indeed.

 
Well I'm not near as old as you geezers but yeah, the swc of my youth doesn't look so bad. Three hated rivals every year and a Cotton bowl berth against a big name opponent as often as not.

 
Back
Top Bottom